Calamari, octopus and shrimp are the three stars of the seafood that comes before the fish at an Istanbul table. In short: calamari is a quick-cooking hot starter, known for crisp fried or charred grilled rings; octopus is simmered until tender and then grilled, finished in butter or served as a salad; shrimp comes baked in a clay pot, cooked in butter or in a cold salad.
Below you will find how calamari and octopus differ, which cooking method suits each one, the seafood on the Yıldızlar menu, and how to order it all as meze and hot starters.
What is the difference between calamari and octopus?
Both are cephalopods, but they look and cook differently:
| Calamari (squid) | Octopus | Cuttlefish | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Body | Long and tube-shaped | Rounded head, no body tube | Broad and flat |
| Limbs | 8 arms + 2 long tentacles | 8 arms | 8 arms + 2 tentacles |
| Internal shell | Thin and clear (the pen) | None | Thick and white (cuttlebone) |
| Cooking | Short and hot | Long simmer first | Short or long |
| On the table | Fried, grilled | Grilled, in butter, salad | Grilled, casserole |
The practical rule: if there are rings on your plate, it is almost always calamari; thick, curling arms with suckers mean octopus.
Calamari: fried or grilled?
The golden rule for calamari is to cook it briefly. Squid cooks in a minute or two over high heat; leave it longer and it toughens. (Cooked very long and slow it softens again, which is why squid is cooked either very quickly or for a long time; anything in between turns rubbery.)
Fried calamari (kalamar tava) is rings dusted in flour and fried in hot oil. Crisp outside, tender inside, it comes with tarator (a garlic and walnut sauce) or lemon. It is one of the most loved hot starters with beer or rakı.
Grilled calamari (kalamar ızgara) is lighter. The squid is cooked whole or in rings over the coals for a short time and finished with a little chilli flakes and olive oil. It is a good choice if you would rather avoid frying or enjoy the clean taste of the squid.
Octopus: why is it simmered first?

Octopus muscle is rich in connective tissue; put straight on the grill it turns tough and rubbery. So octopus is first simmered in its own juices or a little water until tender. Only then does it get its finishing touch:
- Grilled octopus (ahtapot ızgara): the simmered arms are charred briefly over the coals, slightly crisp outside and soft inside, served with olive oil and lemon.
- Octopus in butter (tereyağında ahtapot): the arms are cooked with butter, garlic and peppers in a hot dish that arrives sizzling.
- Octopus salad (ahtapot salatası): simmered octopus, chopped and dressed with olive oil, lemon, parsley and onion, served as a cold meze.
The test of a well-prepared octopus is simple: it cuts easily with a fork.
Shrimp: casserole, butter and salad
Shrimp is one of the most ordered hot starters on an Istanbul table and comes three main ways:
- Shrimp casserole (karides güveç): peeled shrimp baked with tomato, peppers, onion and garlic in a small clay pot. Some kitchens top it with kaşar cheese. It arrives bubbling, and dipping bread in the sauce is all but compulsory.
- Butter shrimp (tereyağında karides) and jumbo shrimp in butter (tereyağında jumbo karides): shrimp cooked in butter and garlic in a hot pan. The jumbo shrimp is one of Yıldızlar’s signature dishes.
- Shrimp salad (karides salatası): cooked shrimp with greens and lemon, served as a cold meze.
The cooking rule is the same as for calamari: shrimp is ready the moment it turns pink and curls; any longer and it dries out.
Seafood in the meze and hot-starter order

An Istanbul fish dinner moves from cold to hot. Seafood appears twice in that order:
- As cold meze: octopus salad, shrimp salad, stuffed mussels, lakerda (cured bonito) and çiroz (dried mackerel). These arrive with the first plates.
- As hot starters (ara sıcak): fried or grilled calamari, shrimp casserole, butter shrimp, grilled octopus, octopus in butter and crab claws. These come after the cold meze and before the fish.
For two people, two or three cold meze, one or two hot starters and then a fish to share is a comfortable pace. If you cannot decide, the mixed hot starter plate is an easy way to taste several hot dishes at once. Our rakı and meze guide covers which plates suit rakı, and our guide to grilled, fried, poached or salt-baked fish helps you choose how the fish that follows should be cooked.
Seafood on the Yıldızlar menu
| Dish | How it comes | Section |
|---|---|---|
| Kalamar Tava (fried calamari) | Flour-dusted, crisp rings | Hot starters |
| Kalamar Izgara (grilled calamari) | Over the coals, simple | Hot starters |
| Ahtapot Izgara (grilled octopus) | Simmered, then charred | Hot starters |
| Tereyağında Ahtapot (octopus in butter) | With butter and garlic, in a hot dish | Hot starters |
| Karides Güveç (shrimp casserole) | Baked in a clay pot | Hot starters |
| Tereyağında Karides (butter shrimp) | With butter and garlic | Hot starters |
| Tereyağında Jumbo Karides | Large shrimp in butter | Hot starters |
| Pavurya Bacağı (crab claws) | Crab claws | Hot starters |
| Ahtapot Salatası (octopus salad) | With olive oil and lemon, cold | Seafood meze |
| Karides Salatası (shrimp salad) | With greens, cold | Seafood meze |
| Midye Dolma (stuffed mussels) | Mussels stuffed with spiced rice | Seafood meze |
The menu can change with the season and the day’s catch, so ask your waiter what is available.
Allergy and dietary notes
- Crustaceans (shrimp, crab) and molluscs (calamari, octopus, mussels) are common allergens. If you have an allergy, tell your waiter before you order.
- Dishes cooked in butter contain dairy; you can ask whether a casserole has cheese on top.
- If you do not eat seafood, the menu also has vegetable dishes, vegetarian meze and meat dishes.
An evening of seafood at Yıldızlar
Yıldızlar Restaurant has been on the Galata Bridge since 1980 and today sits on the lower level of the new bridge at the Eminönü end, facing the Bosphorus. We are open every day from 10:00 to 02:00. You can set the whole table by the water, from cold meze and hot starters to a fish chosen from the display.
See all seafood and hot starters on our menu, then reserve your table with the online form. For groups of 10 to 200 people, see events and group bookings.




